A philosopher’s argument against the cult of achievement | Zena Hitz: Full Interview

Zena Hitz presents a compelling and articulate argument against the prevailing culture of achievement, drawing on her personal experiences and philosophical training. Her critique of academia and the instrumentalization of education is well-founded and resonates with broader societal concerns. The interview is intellectually stimulating, offering a nuanced perspective on the value of intellectual life as a human good rather than a means to status or wealth. Hitz’s use of Aristotle and the concept of ’telic’ activities provides a solid philosophical framework, though she could have delved deeper into the practical implications of her ideas. The discussion is largely anecdotal, relying on personal narrative rather than empirical evidence, which may limit its generalizability. However, her points are logically coherent and ethically grounded. The interview’s strength lies in its accessibility and the sincerity of her message, which challenges viewers to reflect on their own values and priorities. The adéquation between title and content is strong, as the interview indeed focuses on her argument against achievement culture. Overall, this is a thought-provoking and valuable contribution to the discourse on education and human flourishing, though it would benefit from more concrete examples and engagement with counterarguments.

The title accurately reflects the core theme: a philosopher's critique of achievement culture and her argument for a more humanistic intellectual life.

8/10

The interview features a philosopher with academic credentials, presenting a coherent argument grounded in personal experience and references to philosophical traditions (Aristotle, telic/atelic activities). The discussion is nuanced and avoids overgeneralization, though it relies heavily on anecdotal evidence and personal narrative rather than empirical data.

• 00:00The journey of a disillusioned academic
• 08:52What is an intellectual life
• 14:54Aristotle and human flourishing
• 27:30The philosophy of washing dishes
• 29:19Unlikely intellectuals, from Einstein to MC Hammer

• Big Think Membership — Promotional link for Big Think membership, mentioned in the video description.
• Big Think Membership (with UTM) — Another promotional link for Big Think membership.
• Video Transcript — Link to the transcript of this interview, referenced in the description.
• Big Think on Substack — Subscription link for Big Think's Substack newsletter.
• Big Think Interviews on Spotify — Podcast version of Big Think interviews.
• Up next: Love, sex, and happiness, explained by philosophy | Jonny Thomson — Link to a related Big Think interview mentioned in the description.

• Lost in Thought: The Hidden Pleasures of an Intellectual Life — Zena Hitz's book, which expands on the themes discussed in the interview.

• The Cult of Achievement — Some critics argue that achievement culture also has positive aspects, such as motivating innovation and progress, which Hitz does not fully address.